1. Introduction
The global elevator market is projected to grow annually by an average of 4.64%[1]. By 2024, it is expected to reach 161.7 billion USD. This growth is driven by the introduction of smart technologies, the expansion of Internet of Things (IoT)-based platforms, an aging population, and increased construction activity[2]. In many countries, the number of elevators used for vertical and horizontal transportation is rapidly increasing owing to urbanization and the surge in high-rise buildings. The increasing number of shopping malls, airports, train stations, and subway stations in metropolitan areas has also increased demand for horizontal transportation systems that can accommodate large crowds. However, with the rise of convenience facilities, the number of related accidents is also increasing annually[3]. These changes have significantly influenced daily life, underscoring the importance of maintaining a balance between work and leisure. For instance, during the Lunar New Year holiday in 2025, Incheon International Airport is projected to record an average of 219,800 daily passengers. As a major hub, the airport serves approximately 106 million passengers annually[4]. Passengers transitioned to cars, often using escalators with luggage. Those traveling by car also use escalators to travel from parking lots to terminals. Most travelers prefer escalators over elevators because of their bulky or heavy luggage. The parking lot currently utilizes the existing elevator shaft during expansion; however, the newly installed escalator differs from the original in step height. This disparity is particularly noticeable when the escalator is stationary. Compared with general stairs, escalator steps are usually higher, requiring users to lift their knees higher than normal. When descending, the stairs may be higher than what a person is accustomed to, making it harder to maintain balance, especially in the case of an emergency stop or accident, which may increase the risk of falls. To prevent such accidents, it is essential to be mindful of step height and to follow established safety rules. When using an escalator, the notice sign typically reads in English, ‘Hold the handrail.’ However, most users do not follow this instruction[5]. This behavior may be related to concerns regarding dirt from shared surfaces or the inconvenience of holding their cell phones. Direct observations of passengers on subway station escalators showed that, on average, only 3 out of 40 individuals held handrails, while the rest did not use handrails or simply moved with their elbows. Because of this neglect of safety rules, escalator accidents have increased, underscoring the need for better preparation and preventive measures. Large department stores and shopping malls often lack adequate evacuation routes compared to their capacity[6]. Evacuation stairs at department stores and large shopping malls are less noticeable and are intended to encourage users to focus more on shopping using escalators. Consequently, in the event of a fire or disaster, most passengers attempt to evacuate using escalators that have stopped in response to fire alarms. Previous studies have examined evacuation methods involving escalators in subway stations[7] and simultaneous evacuation using escalators and stairs[8-10]. However, research on the effectiveness of escalator-based evacuation remains limited. To address this gap, an evacuation study using Pathfinder was conducted. Escalators are widely installed in shopping malls and subway stations and are primarily used by unfamiliar people rather than those familiar with the building layout. During a disaster, instead of quickly locating evacuation stairs, occupants often attempt to evacuate via the escalators they usually use. In fire emergencies, escalators are frequently used for evacuation; however, their safety is compromised when they are stopped, as users may struggle to maintain balance owing to step height differences, potentially leading to accidents. Moreover, elevators should be avoided in fire situations because of the risk of exposure to smoke and flames, although fire-rated elevators can be used if they meet specific safety standards[7,11].
This study investigates how reducing escalator step height affects evacuation when the escalator is stopped, whether going up or down. Escalators are widely installed in commercial and transportation facilities, but they account for a considerable proportion of elevator-related accidents, particularly among vulnerable groups such as children and older adults. Many of these incidents are attributed to user negligence, inconsistent step heights, or insufficient safety compliance with safety guidelines. Additionally, this study was conducted to confirm the efficiency of using an escalator tread as a staircase during various disasters. The goal was to reduce the evacuation time when evacuating using an escalator.
2. Background
2.1. Escalator installation status
As buildings increase in size, amenities, such as elevators, escalators, and moving walkways, are included[3]. The number of elevators installed is increasing every year. According to data from the National Elevator Information Center, the total number of elevators in Korea is projected to reach 866,669 by 2025. Escalators account for 94.6% of the total, elevators for 4.1%, and moving walkways for 0.7%.
Department stores, large shopping malls, and large box stores have favored installing escalators rather than elevators because of the consumer behavior in retail environments. Customers tend to browse slowly across multiple floors, resulting in frequent movements between levels and extended stays[12]. In large stores, many customers use shopping carts; therefore, conveyor belts are installed to ensure efficient movement.
Table 1 shows that escalators were installed in 48.72% of large shopping malls and 23.53% of subway stations[9]. In addition to Lines 1-8, which are managed by the Seoul Transportation Corporation, most subway stations—including those on the Gyeongui-Jungang, Shinbundang, and Suinbundang Lines—are equipped with escalators.
2.2. Escalator accident factors
Escalators accounted for 4.91% of all elevator-related facilities. In 2019, one major accident was reported, and two more occurred in 2024, resulting in death, hospitalization for more than a week, or treatment lasting over three weeks. Falls on escalators can result in minor abrasions or fatal outcomes, with varying impacts based on sex[13-15]. In general, taller staircases in buildings are associated with higher accident rates among older adults compared to younger individuals[16].
Escalator accidents often result from user negligence or unsafe usage patterns, such as falling and jamming. Younger individuals are more likely to experience accidents, such as falls or collisions, because of curiosity and exploratory behavior. Conversely, older individuals, who generally have lower cognitive abilities and slower physical responses, are more likely to stumble or trip. Unlike elevator accidents, escalator accidents typically impact vulnerable populations, particularly children under 13 years (20.7%) and seniors aged 65 years or older (38.3%) (Kwon et al. 2012). During summer, accidents are mainly caused by sand. In addition to user behavior, accidents may also result from mechanical problems or defects in the escalator itself. Common causes include damaged steps, step jamming, cracked glass at the bottom of the handrail, and smoke generation[17,18].
According to the Seoul Transportation Corporation Management Evaluation Report 2024, 1,098 cases of user negligence were recorded. Of these, 4.29% were classified by accident type, including falls (913 cases, 83.15%), accidents caused by jamming (68 cases, 6.19%), falls caused by a third party (39 cases, 3.55%), and stoppages due to defective parts. The sign ‘Hold the handrail’ is prominently displayed on escalators; however, most passengers do not comply. Several factors contribute to this behavior, such as holding a cell phone while using the escalator or avoiding the handrail because of concerns about dirt or contamination. Even when passengers are carrying mobile phones, many deliberately avoid touching the handrails for hygiene reasons[19]. With rising awareness of personal hygiene and hand cleanliness, passengers using escalators have been seen as not holding handrails[20].
Noise pollution is also a widespread issue in modern times, and the use of noise-canceling earphones or headsets has become relatively high[21]. These devices block external sounds so effectively that once worn, no sound can be heard, even if an accident occurs at the top of the escalator.
Article 18 of the ‘Operation Regulations on Safe Operation and Management of Elevators,’ a notice issued by the Ministry of the Interior and Safety, states: ‘When using an escalator or inclined moving walkway, you must hold the handrail’[22]. Furthermore, the practice of “tightrope walking” during the 2002 World Cup led to the adoption of walking escalators. However, this practice has led to numerous accidents involving not only the individuals themselves but also third parties, owing to falls while walking or running on escalators[23]. Such incidents often injure both the person using the escalator and the passengers behind them simultaneously. Older adults and people with disabilities, who may struggle to keep up with the escalator’s standard speed of 0.5 m/s, are particularly vulnerable[24].
If an escalator stops suddenly—whether triggered by a fire signal or losing its center of gravity owing to an emergency stop from pinching, a fall, or a collision by a third party—reducing the height between the tread and the stepping board may help lower the risk of imbalance and falls.
2.3. Comparison of domestic and international laws
Escalator height regulations in the USA (Canada), the United Kingdom (Europe), and South Korea (ASME[25]; BS EN115[26]; Escalator Safety Standards[27]).
According to Figure 1, escalator regulations in the USA (Canada) mandate a maximum step height of 8.5 inches (220 mm). In the UK (Europe) and South Korea, the maximum allowed step height for escalators is 0.24 m (240 mm).
Stair height regulations in the USA, the UK, and South Korea (Rules on Standards for Evacuation and Fire Prevention Structures of Buildings[28]).
According to USA stair regulations, the height of the staircase should not exceed 7 3 4 inches, and the deviation of each step should not exceed 3 8 inches. Additionally, the UK's stairs regulations state that the height of the stairs should be between 150 and 220 mm, and no deviations are permitted between steps.
Compared with other countries, South Korea's stair height regulations are limited. Current guidelines specify that the height of the stairs in elementary schools should not exceed 160 mm, and those in middle and high schools should not exceed 180 mm; however, no regulations exist for other types of buildings. A comparison of stair heights in buildings with escalators across the U.S., U.K., and South Korea highlights notable differences. In the U.S., normal stairs are 7 inches high, whereas escalator steps are 8.5 inches high. In the U.K., normal building stairs range from 150 to 220 mm, while escalators are 240 mm high. In South Korea, the heights of normal building stairs are 160 mm and 180 mm, which is significantly lower than the height of the escalator steps.
Elevator regulations in the USA are outlined in the International Building Code (IBC) Chapter 30 and National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) Code 70, Chapter 6. They are also outlined in ASME A.17.1, which specifies that the depth of the stair treads must be at least 400 mm (15.75 in) and the height between treads should not exceed 220 mm (8.5 in). Canada’s escalator regulations (CSAB44) follow the same standard, with a maximum height of 220 mm. In Europe, Regulation 1150 of European Standard EN 8.1.1 states that the height between escalator treads should not exceed 0.24 m. South Korea’s stair height regulation is also set at 0.24 m, consistent with the UK and Europe. In the USA and Canada, escalator stairs are less than 220 mm, whereas in Europe, they are 240 mm, and in South Korea, they are 240 mm. This results in a difference of approximately 38 mm in the USA, up to 90 mm in the UK, and 80 mm in South Korea when comparing general staircase heights to escalator stairs.
3. Methods
3.1. Evacuation simulation conditions
The total number of participants in the simulation was 100 (50 men and 50 women). Of these, 25 men and 25 women were aged 10-39, while the remaining 25 men and 25 women were aged 60-79 years. These age groups were selected due to their high usage of escalators at subway stations, which are commonly used by office workers, students, and older adults. Individuals aged 40 years or older were excluded from the study, as they typically rely on cars for transportation. This study also considered standard human body indices for South Koreans, including walking speed and shoulder width. Because this study employed a computerized evacuation simulation and did not involve actual human participants, formal ethical approval was deemed unnecessary.
Choi et al.[29] reported average evacuation speed values for men and women during downward movement. In the event of a fire or other building disaster, both men and women evacuate faster than normal walking speeds.
Walking vertically, such as climbing stairs or navigating broken escalators, requires greater effort and thus consumes more energy than walking on level ground[30]. According to Frantzich[31], when descending stairs, individuals typically move at speeds ranging from 0.69 to 0.72 m/s, regardless of the stair width. In emergency situations where escalators are used for evacuation, or when rapid movement is required, walking speeds in simulations are often adjusted accordingly. During disasters, evacuation behavior can be influenced by social dynamics. Individuals tend to follow the pace of their companions or those around them[32]. This can affect decisions made by pedestrians while evacuating[33-36].
To evaluate the impact of stair height during evacuation, we conducted an evacuation simulation. The escalator examined was 65 m long—the longest in South Korea—compared with the national average escalator length of 25 m. The tread height varied, with European and domestic regulations set at 240 mm and 220 mm in the USA (215 mm). The actual height of the escalator installed in the extension of the Incheon International Airport was 180 mm. During evacuation, factors such as walking speed and age were incorporated into the model. To compare scenarios in which bottlenecks occurred[37,38], the left lane was assigned to ordinary adult, and the right lane was assigned to older adults based on walking speed.
3.2 .The Pathfinder experiment
The evacuation simulation was conducted six times under different scenarios (Figure 2), and the results were collected using the Pathfinder experiment[39-42].
The simulation experimental conditions were as follows: When the escalator was 65 m long, the escalator step heights were 240, 215, and 180 mm and were computerized three times (pathfinder). When the escalator was 25 m long, the evacuation times for the six conditions were compared by simulating escalator step heights of 240, 215, and 180 mm.
The escalator was set to 65 m to match the longest escalator installed at Guri Station on the Korean light rail, whereas the average length for the other subway stations was 25 m. The stair height was adjusted to 215 mm to comply with the U.S. standard of 220 mm or less, and the minimum height of Incheon International Airport was set to 180 mm to meet the same standard.
In the comparative experiment, when the escalator was stopped, people with slow walking speeds were directed to the right to evacuate, and those with high walking speeds were directed to the left. We experimented with two escalator entrances and two exits. In the event of a disaster, everyone was instructed to use the escalator without distinction. In these situations, both the escalator entrance and exit were set to one, and both scenarios were tested to measure their impact on evacuation time.
4. Results
Table 2 presents the simulation results, analyzing the evacuation time based on stair height during emergency stop situations and fires. Simulations (1, 2, and 3) calculated the time required for all 100 participants to evacuate when the escalator length was 65 m[43]. The available safe egress time (ASET) was defined as the required safe egress time (RSET) plus additional margin time. During emergency stops, the European and Korean standard of 240 mm required 328.5 s for evacuation, while the U.S. standard of 215 mm took 306.0 s, and the 180 mm height took 38.7 s. Furthermore, the evacuation time during emergency situations, such as a fire or disaster, was observed to be 243.0 s for the 240 mm height, 224.0 s for the 215 mm height, and 209.8 s for the 180 mm height, showing a difference of 33.2 s between the fastest and slowest evacuation times.
Simulations 4, 5, and 6 represent the time required for all 100 participants to evacuate when the escalator length was set at 25 m. Evacuation times were recorded as 224.3 s for 240 mm, 211.8 s for 215 mm, and 199.5 s for 180 mm, indicating that the evacuation time varies depending on the height of the stairs. In an emergency, evacuation times were 166.5 s at 240 mm, 156.5 s at 215 mm, and 143.0 s at 180 mm, indicating a maximum evacuation time difference of 23.5 seconds. These results are summarized in Figure 3, which shows that for both 65 m and 25 m escalators, greater step heights were associated with longer evacuation times.
Table 3 shows the evacuation patterns during a disaster or unexpected events, such as emergency stops. A comparison was made between two scenarios: (1) fast evacuation regardless of age or sex, and (2) evacuation when older participants were directed to the right and younger participants to the left. Evacuation times when passing through the designated passages in Table 3 were compared to those when not passing through.
When the escalator length was 65 m and the stair height was 240 mm, the time difference for evacuating in the specified direction was 389.5 s, compared to 283.8 s for evacuating in the order of entry. This resulted in a time difference of 105.7 s, which can be clearly seen in Figure 4.
When comparing the height of the stairs at 180 mm to the length of the escalator at 25 m, the time difference was 241.8 s when traveling left and right and 190.8 s when evacuating quickly in a specific order, as shown in Figure 5. During the simulation, older individuals generally took longer to move to the right, whereas younger participants used the left staircase, even in bottleneck situations where they pushed each other. Additionally, as evacuees started evacuating to the left, they pushed others forward and then returned to the left or moved down before finally turning left to pass through the left gate.
Generally, it takes longer to pass through a gate in the event of a bottleneck.
5. Discussion
This study proposes strategies to increase evacuation efficiency using escalators in various disaster situations. Specifically, it examined how stair height affects evacuees’ movement to the evacuation floor when escalators are not operational. Previous research has shown that evacuation using escalators is feasible in underground settings [9], and can be effective for evacuating people from the upper floors of large underground buildings[8]. During building fires, elevators typically cease operation and transport users to the designated evacuation floor. Similarly, escalators also stop and remain stationary. Passengers must evacuate by using stationary escalators. Research has indicated that using escalators during a fire can alleviate the congestion in evacuation staircases, thereby supporting a more efficient evacuation process[7].
Experiment results demonstrated that reducing the height of escalator stairs shortens evacuation time. Escalator length also plays a significant role in the evacuation time based on the height of the stairs. In the event of clothing or shoe entrapment causing the escalator to stop, users may struggle to move quickly, which is a known challenge. Adherence to safety regulations is crucial for preventing such incidents. Observing the increasing trend of ‘Smombies’ [44] (individuals distracted by smartphones while walking) further emphasizes the importance of prioritizing safety. Additionally, the use of noise-canceling earphones can prevent individuals from becoming aware of their surroundings, potentially leading to collisions or accidents.
Owing to the limitations of current simulations, accurately modeling scenarios such as an individual falling on an escalator or a bag tumbling downward remains difficult. Furthermore, during bottleneck situations, existing programs often unrealistically push individuals towards their original input positions[45]. These limitations highlight the need for further developments in simulation tools to better reflect real-world dynamics. In real-world fire or disaster scenarios, building residents frequently prefer escalators over emergency stairs for evacuation. A simulation-based study was conducted to investigate the effect of escalator stair height on the evacuation efficiency under these conditions. Future studies should integrate more realistic human behavior modeling with dynamic physical interactions to increase the applicability of simulation results to real-world emergencies.
6. Conclusion
This study analyzed the impact of escalator stair height on evacuation efficiency during building emergencies through experimental simulations. The aim of this study was to evaluate the influence of structural design elements, particularly stair height and escalator length, on evacuation speed and safety. The key findings are summarized as follows:
1) Effect of Reducing Escalator Stair Height
Lowering the height of escalator stairs significantly improved the evacuation speed and reduced the likelihood of casualties. For long escalators, the time difference exceeded 30 s, and the effect was particularly noticeable for individuals unfamiliar with the building layout, offering a quicker means of evacuation.
2) Impact of Escalators Length on Evacuation Efficiency
As long escalators become more common in high-rise buildings, the stair height tends to decrease, which may negatively impact evacuation efficiency. As escalators can serve as critical evacuation routes when emergency stairways are difficult to locate, improvements in design and regulatory standards are necessary.
3) Limitations of Simulation Tools and Future Directions
Existing simulation tools (the Pathfinder used in this experiment) have limitations in accurately reflecting dynamic behaviors, such as sudden body movements or falls during emergency stops. Future studies should focus on developing more realistic simulations that incorporate these factors. Additionally, experimental efforts should be made to standardize stair height regulations across different countries. Integrating realistic human behavior models is also essential for enhancing the practicality of evacuation strategies and the effectiveness of disaster response planning.







